Photo: Cathedral of Christ the Light, Oakland. Photo by Skier Dude (opens in a new tab), licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
An Alameda County jury has awarded $14.3 million to a survivor who was sexually abused as a child by former Catholic priest Stephen Kiesle in the 1970s, SNAP Network reported (opens in a new tab).
Yesterday’s verdict marks the second multimillion-dollar jury award against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland involving Kiesle in just seven months.
In April, another jury awarded $16 million to a different survivor abused by the same former priest.
The Oakland Diocese is still attempting to resolve hundreds of clergy sexual abuse claims through bankruptcy proceedings. And the two jury awards could complicate efforts to reach a broader settlement.
Who Is Former Oakland Diocese Priest Stephen Kiesle?
Kiesle was ordained in 1972 and served at several East Bay Catholic parishes, including churches in Oakland, Union City and Pinole.
His history of sexual misconduct allegations stretches back decades.
In 1978, he was arrested following allegations that he molested two boys. He received probation and counseling.
He was removed from the priesthood in 1987.
Kiesle later faced additional criminal accusations involving children. In 2004, he pleaded no contest to sexually abusing a girl and was sentenced to six years in prison.
According to reporting by the San Francisco Chronicle, Kiesle has been accused of abusing at least 15 children and has been named in approximately 60 lawsuits brought under California’s expanded childhood sexual abuse laws.
He is currently incarcerated following a separate conviction for gross vehicular manslaughter involving a fatal drunken-driving incident.
For the survivors who brought the recent civil lawsuits, the cases concern abuse that occurred decades before those later criminal proceedings.
Oakland Diocese Bankruptcy Complicates Compensation for Survivors
The Diocese of Oakland filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in May 2023 while facing more than 330 lawsuits alleging childhood sexual abuse by clergy.
Bankruptcy allows an organization to continue operating while attempting to reorganize its finances and resolve claims against it.
For abuse survivors, however, that process can be complicated.
Rather than having every claim decided by a jury, a diocese may propose a compensation fund intended to resolve hundreds of lawsuits through a single bankruptcy settlement.
The amount available to each survivor can depend on the overall settlement, the number of eligible claims and the procedures established to distribute compensation.
In Oakland, disagreements over the proposed settlement have continued for years.
The diocese has sought to resolve its liabilities through a reorganization plan, while representatives of survivors have challenged the proposed compensation and other terms.
In October 2026, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge William Lafferty rejected the diocese’s proposed plan, finding that it failed to satisfy requirements for bankruptcy court approval.
The ruling left the diocese without a confirmed reorganization plan.
Now, the November $14.3 million verdict adds another major development to an already contentious process.
Survivor advocates have argued that the verdicts should prompt the diocese to reconsider how much compensation it is offering.
The Diocese of Oakland, meanwhile, said in a statement today that it acknowledges the latest jury verdict and remains committed to providing fair compensation to survivors through the bankruptcy process.
Whether the diocese and survivors can reach an agreement that satisfies the bankruptcy court remains uncertain.
Sexual Abuse Lawsuits Against the Catholic Church in California
Hundreds of survivors have filed lawsuits accusing Catholic dioceses and clergy members of childhood sexual abuse. Some cases have resulted in major jury verdicts, while others remain tied up in bankruptcy proceedings and settlement negotiations.
Learn about the ongoing Catholic Church litigation, California’s filing deadlines, and legal options that may still be available to survivors.
California Law Helped Reopen the Courts to Survivors
Many of the lawsuits against the Diocese of Oakland became possible because California expanded the time available to bring childhood sexual abuse claims.
Assembly Bill 218, which took effect in January 2020, temporarily reopened the courts to certain survivors whose claims had previously expired.
The law also expanded the civil filing deadline for childhood sexual assault claims.
That change allowed many adults who experienced abuse decades earlier to pursue lawsuits against individuals and institutions they accused of responsibility.
Both Oakland verdicts involve abuse dating to the 1970s, illustrating how changes to California law have affected litigation involving longstanding claims.
However, filing deadlines are still complicated. Different rules may apply depending on when the abuse occurred, the type of defendant and other circumstances.
What Happens Next for the Oakland Diocese?
The diocese remains in bankruptcy proceedings, with hundreds of clergy sexual abuse claims still awaiting resolution.
The latest verdict does not mean the Diocese of Oakland has reached a global settlement, nor does it guarantee that the survivor will immediately receive the full jury award.
Bankruptcy-related issues, potential appeals and further court proceedings could affect when and how compensation is paid.
Still, the two 2026 verdicts represent significant developments in the litigation.
For survivors who have spent decades seeking accountability for childhood sexual abuse, the cases demonstrate that some longstanding claims can still reach a jury, even while a larger institutional bankruptcy remains unresolved.
RELATED:
Judge Rejects Oakland Diocese’s $180 Million Plan to Compensate Abuse Survivors
Judge Dismisses Oakland Diocese Bankruptcy, Allowing Sexual Abuse Lawsuits to Proceed
Oakland Diocese’s Final Settlement Proposal Offers $242 Million to Abuse Survivors
Oakland Diocese Tries to End Bankruptcy After Years of Mediation Over Abuse Claims
Survivors Testify Against Oakland Diocese Bankruptcy Amid Lawsuits
Largest Catholic Clergy Sexual Abuse Settlements in the United States



