This won’t clear your browser history.

Baltimore Archdiocese, Abuse Survivors Reach Tentative Bankruptcy Agreement

Baltimore Archbishop William E. Lori during a Catholic religious service. The Archdiocese of Baltimore has reached a tentative bankruptcy agreement involving nearly 1,000 clergy sexual abuse claims.

Image: Baltimore Archbishop William E. Lori. Screenshot from the Archdiocese of Baltimore website (opens in a new tab).

After more than three years of bankruptcy proceedings, the Archdiocese of Baltimore and representatives of clergy sexual abuse survivors have reached a tentative agreement that could bring nearly 1,000 claims closer to resolution, The Baltimore Banner reported (opens in a new tab).

The conditional agreement, disclosed during yesterday’s federal bankruptcy court hearing, covers negotiations between the archdiocese and the committee representing survivors. Major questions remain about how much insurance companies, Catholic parishes, schools and other affiliated organizations will contribute.

According to those involved in the proceedings, a final agreement may not come until 2027.

For survivors who have already spent decades seeking accountability for childhood sexual abuse, the additional delay is hardly welcome news.

Judge Frustrated by Years of Delays and Mounting Legal Fees

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Michelle Harner made it clear during the hearing that she’s growing impatient with the pace of negotiations.

The archdiocese filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in September 2023. Since then, survivors, church officials, insurers and other parties have spent years negotiating how to compensate people who were sexually abused by Catholic clergy and other church personnel.

Harner warned that the parties need to find a workable resolution or consider another approach.

A mediator reported that the archdiocese and survivors’ committee had reached a tentative agreement, subject to several conditions.

That represents meaningful progress. But it doesn’t resolve disputes involving the other parties whose contributions may be necessary to fund a comprehensive settlement.

According to CBS News Baltimore (opens in a new tab), the parties also reported progress with insurers. One additional insurance agreement had been reached during the week of the hearing, while negotiations with two other insurers were reportedly approaching resolution.

The challenge now is turning those individual agreements into a bankruptcy plan that can win the required approvals.

Nearly 1,000 Survivors Have Filed Claims

The Archdiocese of Baltimore’s bankruptcy involves approximately 1,000 people who have submitted claims alleging sexual abuse within the Catholic Church.

The archdiocese filed for bankruptcy on September 29, 2023, just two days before Maryland’s Child Victims Act (opens in a new tab) took effect.

That law eliminated the statute of limitations for many civil lawsuits involving childhood sexual abuse, allowing survivors to pursue claims regardless of how long ago the abuse occurred.

The timing of the bankruptcy was significant.

Instead of proceeding individually through Maryland’s civil courts, many lawsuits against the archdiocese became subject to federal bankruptcy proceedings.

A bankruptcy settlement generally involves creating a compensation trust funded by the organization, insurance companies and potentially other affiliated entities.

Survivors then receive compensation according to the terms of an approved plan.

But negotiating that plan can become complicated when the parties disagree over financial contributions, legal responsibility and which assets should be available to compensate survivors.

Those issues remain central to the Baltimore bankruptcy.

Catholic Church Sexual Abuse Lawsuits: Settlements, Bankruptcies and Legal Options

The Archdiocese of Baltimore is one of several Catholic dioceses that have filed for bankruptcy while facing hundreds of childhood sexual abuse claims. These cases raise important questions about compensation, institutional accountability and survivors’ legal rights.

Learn about major Catholic Church sexual abuse settlements, ongoing bankruptcy cases, filing deadlines and legal options for survivors.

→ Read Our Catholic Church Sexual Abuse Lawsuit Guide

Maryland’s Investigation Exposed Decades of Clergy Sexual Abuse

The bankruptcy followed a sweeping investigation by the Maryland Attorney General’s Office into sexual abuse within the Archdiocese of Baltimore.

Released in April 2023, the more than 450-page report documented allegations involving 156 priests and other church personnel who sexually abused more than 600 children over several decades.

The investigation also described how church officials failed to respond adequately to complaints, sometimes allowing accused clergy members to remain in positions where they could encounter additional children.

The findings helped intensify calls for changes to Maryland’s childhood sexual abuse laws.

Later that year, the Child Victims Act took effect, opening new opportunities for survivors to pursue civil accountability.

But the archdiocese’s bankruptcy placed many claims into a different legal process, where survivors are still awaiting a comprehensive resolution.

Survivors Still Waiting as Settlement Talks Continue

For some survivors, the tentative agreement offers renewed hope that the bankruptcy may finally be approaching its conclusion.

Others remain frustrated by the years spent negotiating.

According to CBS Baltimore, one survivor told reporters that more than 20 survivors have died since the bankruptcy proceedings began.

The survivor, who experienced abuse connected to a Baltimore parish and school, said she felt encouraged by the judge’s determination to move the case forward.

Her comments underscore an uncomfortable reality of institutional sexual abuse litigation.

Many survivors are now older adults. Some have been waiting decades for their claims to be heard, and additional years of legal proceedings mean some may never see a resolution.

Meanwhile, the archdiocese has maintained that bankruptcy provides an orderly way to compensate survivors while allowing the church to continue its religious and charitable operations.

Whether the eventual settlement will satisfy survivors and the bankruptcy court remains an open question.

What Happens Next in the Baltimore Archdiocese Bankruptcy?

Negotiations will continue with insurance companies, parishes, schools and other Catholic entities.

The archdiocese and survivors’ committee must also resolve the conditions attached to their tentative agreement.

Any comprehensive reorganization plan would ultimately require approval from the bankruptcy court.

No final settlement amount covering all survivor claims has been announced.

Previous negotiations have included a $100 million agreement with The Hartford insurance company, subject to conditions and bankruptcy court approval. But that agreement represents only one potential contribution to the larger settlement.

The parties have expressed optimism that a broader resolution could be reached in 2027.

Related Coverage:

Baltimore Archdiocese And Survivors To Continue Mediation Through 2026 Bankruptcy Proceedings

Baltimore Archdiocese Says It Will Not Claim Charitable Immunity in Abuse Bankruptcy Case

Survivors Confront Baltimore Archdiocese in Bankruptcy Court Seeking Accountability and Fair Compensation

Baltimore Archdiocese Settlement Offer Sparks Outrage Among Survivors

Survivors Seek Dismissal of Baltimore Archdiocese Bankruptcy Case

Judge rules Baltimore Archdiocese victims can continue testimony in court

Survivors Still Waiting as Baltimore Archdiocese’s Bankruptcy Case Drags On

Judge Clears Path for Baltimore Archdiocese Abuse Survivors to Sue Before Damages Cap Takes Effect

GET A FREE CASE EVALUATION
no pressure. No obligation.

Knowledge Sparks Reform for Survivors.
Share This Story With Your Network.

Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success