Image: Jehovah’s Witnesses official logo. Source: Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania / Wikimedia Commons (opens in a new tab). Public domain.
A woman who says she was sexually abused as a teenager in an Oregon Jehovah’s Witness congregation is suing the religious organization’s national headquarters, alleging that church policies helped protect abusers instead of children, National Public Radio affiliate KLCC reported (opens in a new tab).
The federal lawsuit targets the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, along with the Junction City East Kingdom Hall of Jehovah’s Witnesses and two men accused of abuse.
At the center of the case is a controversial Jehovah’s Witness policy known as the two-witness rule, which the plaintiff says prevented religious leaders from taking action after she reported abuse.
Woman Says Abuse Began When She Was 14
According to the complaint, the woman was 14 years old when three men associated with a Jehovah’s Witness congregation in Junction City, Oregon, began grooming and sexually abusing her in the early 1990s.
She alleges that religious pressure and the authority of church members made it difficult to resist the abuse or seek help.
When she eventually reported what happened, she says congregation leaders failed to take appropriate action.
Instead, according to the lawsuit, she was told that another witness would need to corroborate her allegations.
The lawsuit contends that the response allowed the alleged misconduct to go unaddressed and subjected her to further harm.
One of the three men accused of abuse has since died. The two surviving men are named as defendants.
But the plaintiff isn’t pursuing claims solely against the individuals allegedly responsible for abusing her.
She also wants to hold the larger religious organization accountable for policies she contends contributed to the abuse and its aftermath.
What Is the Jehovah’s Witnesses’ Two-Witness Rule?
The two-witness rule is an internal religious standard used by Jehovah’s Witnesses when determining whether allegations of serious wrongdoing have been established for congregational disciplinary purposes.
Generally, the rule requires either an admission of wrongdoing or corroborating testimony from two witnesses before certain internal disciplinary action can proceed.
Critics argue that applying this standard to childhood sexual abuse creates an obvious problem.
Sexual abuse often occurs in private, without anyone else present. Requiring a second witness can therefore make it extraordinarily difficult for a child to have an allegation substantiated through the congregation’s internal process.
In the Oregon lawsuit, the woman alleges that this requirement was used to dismiss or disregard her report.
The distinction between religious discipline and civil law is important, however.
A congregation’s internal evidentiary standards do not replace state child-abuse reporting requirements. Religious leaders may have legal obligations to report suspected abuse regardless of whether the allegations satisfy their own disciplinary rules.
The plaintiff argues that Jehovah’s Witness policies interfered with those responsibilities.
Oregon Sexual Abuse Lawsuits: Know Your Legal Options
Survivors of childhood sexual abuse may have grounds to pursue legal action against individuals and institutions that failed to protect them, including religious organizations, schools and residential facilities.
Learn about Oregon’s sexual abuse laws, filing deadlines, institutional liability and how survivors can explore their legal options.
Lawsuit Accuses Watchtower of Institutional Failures
The federal complaint alleges that Watchtower’s policies contributed to negligence, failures to comply with Oregon’s mandatory child-abuse reporting laws, and continuing harm to the plaintiff.
The lawsuit also includes a claim under federal human-trafficking law, alleging that religious coercion played a role in the abuse.
Human-trafficking laws are often associated with organized exploitation or commercial sexual abuse. Here, the plaintiff is attempting to apply federal trafficking protections to alleged misconduct involving religious authority and coercion.
Whether that legal theory can succeed will depend on how the court evaluates the allegations and the requirements of federal law.
The complaint also describes consequences that allegedly continued long after the woman left Oregon.
After moving to Colorado, she says information about her earlier abuse allegations became an issue within another Jehovah’s Witness congregation.
She alleges that religious leaders used the matter against her during divorce proceedings and that she was eventually disfellowshipped, essentially expelled from the congregation.
According to the lawsuit, the resulting family separation, social isolation and shunning contributed to lasting emotional and financial difficulties.
Jehovah’s Witnesses Deny Protecting Sexual Abusers
In response to KLCC’s reporting, the Watchtower Society declined to discuss the specific lawsuit but issued a statement defending its approach to child sexual abuse.
The organization said it considers child sexual abuse both a serious religious offense and a crime.
It also maintained that congregation elders do not protect perpetrators from legal consequences and that children’s safety is a priority.
Those statements contrast sharply with the plaintiff’s allegations that religious leaders failed to act after learning about her abuse.
Similar Allegations Have Surfaced in Other States
The Oregon lawsuit isn’t the first to question how Jehovah’s Witness congregations handle childhood sexual abuse allegations.
In Washington, a 2022 lawsuit accused the religious organization of maintaining policies that favored internal handling of abuse reports rather than immediately contacting authorities.
A separate California lawsuit filed in 2019 also raised concerns about the handling of sexual abuse allegations within Jehovah’s Witness congregations.
What Is the Oregon Plaintiff Seeking?
The woman is seeking compensatory and punitive damages, along with attorney fees.
She is also requesting changes to Watchtower’s policies, including reforms intended to ensure compliance with mandatory child-abuse reporting requirements.
The case, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon, is still in its early stages.
For the plaintiff, the lawsuit is an effort to seek accountability for alleged abuse that began more than three decades ago.



