This won’t clear your browser history.

LDS Sexual Abuse Survivors Ask U.S. Supreme Court to Review Clergy Reporting Ruling

Official flag of the U.S. Supreme Court, where LDS Church sexual abuse survivors are seeking review of an Arizona ruling concerning clergy confidentiality and mandatory child-abuse reporting.
Summary: Three childhood sexual abuse survivors are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review an Arizona ruling protecting LDS bishops who failed to report abuse. The case raises national questions about clergy confidentiality and mandatory child-abuse reporting laws.

Image: United States Supreme Court flag. Image by the Supreme Court of the United States, via Wikimedia Commons (opens in a new tab). Public domain.

Three childhood sexual abuse survivors are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to review an Arizona ruling that protected leaders of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) from liability for failing to report abuse they knew was occurring, Tuscon’s KVOA News Channel 4 reported (opens in a new tab).

The case centers on a father who admitted sexually abusing his children to Mormon bishops, yet the abuse was never reported to law enforcement by those church leaders.

In July 2026, the Arizona Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the bishops were protected under the state’s clergy confidentiality exemption.

Now, the survivors want the nation’s highest court to reconsider that decision.

But the dispute goes well beyond one Arizona congregation.

At issue is whether religious organizations can determine for themselves which communications are confidential, and whether courts can question those determinations when children are being abused.

The U.S. Supreme Court has not yet agreed to hear the case.

Bishops Knew About Abuse but Did Not Report It

The lawsuit stems from years of sexual abuse involving children in a family living in Bisbee, Arizona.

Around 2011, Paul Adams admitted to LDS Bishop John Herrod that he had sexually abused one of his daughters.

Herrod subsequently arranged another meeting involving Adams and his wife, during which Adams again acknowledged the abuse.

The information was later passed to another bishop, Robert “Kim” Mauzy, who convened a church disciplinary council. Adams admitted his misconduct during that proceeding and was subsequently excommunicated.

Despite those disclosures, neither bishop reported the abuse to police or child-protection authorities.

The abuse continued until federal investigators discovered evidence of the crimes in 2017.

Adams was arrested and later died by suicide in jail before standing trial. His wife, Leizza Adams, pleaded guilty to child-abuse charges and received a 30-month prison sentence.

Three of the children subsequently filed a civil lawsuit against the LDS Church and church leaders, alleging negligence, breach of fiduciary duty and other claims arising partly from the failure to report the abuse.

The central question became whether the bishops had a legal obligation to notify authorities, or whether Arizona law allowed them to keep the disclosures confidential.

LDS Church Sexual Abuse Lawsuits: What Survivors Should Know

Sexual abuse lawsuits involving The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints have raised questions about how Church leaders respond to abuse allegations, their reporting responsibilities and when religious institutions can be held legally accountable.

Learn about recent lawsuits, clergy reporting disputes, filing deadlines and legal options for survivors.

→ Read Our LDS Church Sexual Abuse Lawsuit Guide

Arizona Supreme Court Sided With the LDS Church

Arizona law generally requires people who reasonably suspect child abuse to report it to authorities.

But the law includes an exemption for clergy members who receive certain confidential communications or confessions.

Under that provision, clergy may withhold information when they determine that doing so is reasonable and necessary under their religious beliefs.

The LDS Church argued that Adams’ admissions fell within that exemption.

In July, the Arizona Supreme Court agreed.

The justices ruled that courts must give substantial deference to religious organizations when determining whether communications qualify as confessions or confidential religious disclosures.

The court also concluded that the First Amendment generally prevents judges and juries from second-guessing clergy members’ interpretation of their religious obligations.

That decision reversed a 2025 Arizona appeals court ruling that would have allowed further examination of whether the bishops were legally required to report the abuse.

For the survivors, the July ruling effectively blocked their claims against the church defendants over the failure to report their father’s conduct.

Survivors Challenge Who Gets to Define a Confidential Communication

The survivors’ Supreme Court petition challenges a fundamental aspect of Arizona’s ruling.

Should a religious organization be allowed to decide that a conversation is confidential simply because its doctrine treats it that way?

Or should a judge or jury be able to examine the circumstances and determine whether the communication actually qualifies for an exemption under state law?

A private confession to a religious leader may qualify for legal protection. But what happens when an admission is repeated in front of a spouse or a larger disciplinary council?

The survivors argue that the Arizona Supreme Court gave religious organizations too much authority to define confidentiality for themselves.

They also contend that the First Amendment does not require courts to exempt religious leaders from generally applicable child-abuse reporting laws when communications are not genuinely confidential.

The LDS Church has maintained that its clergy were acting within the protections established by Arizona law and that civil courts should not reinterpret religious doctrine.

The dispute places two important interests in tension: protecting religious freedom and ensuring that suspected child abuse is reported to authorities.

The Supreme Court Appeal Beyond Arizona

Although the case originated in Arizona, the constitutional questions could have implications for religious institutions nationwide.

States have different mandatory-reporting requirements and different protections for confidential clergy communications.

Some provide broad exemptions for religious confessions. Others impose additional reporting obligations or place narrower limits on confidentiality.

The survivors’ petition asks the U.S. Supreme Court to address how the First Amendment applies when a state requires reporting of child abuse but also recognizes religious confidentiality.

A decision could potentially clarify whether courts may independently examine the circumstances surrounding a disclosure rather than accepting a religious organization’s interpretation of its own confidentiality rules.

The issue isn’t limited to the LDS Church.

Catholic dioceses and other religious organizations have also faced questions about clergy confidentiality and their obligations to report suspected child abuse.

In fact, Catholic dioceses in Arizona supported the LDS Church’s position during the state Supreme Court proceedings, arguing that religious freedom protections were at stake.

However, even if the U.S. Supreme Court accepts the case, its eventual decision would not necessarily eliminate clergy confidentiality exemptions nationwide. The outcome would depend on the constitutional questions the justices agree to consider and how narrowly or broadly they rule.

LDS Church’s Abuse Reporting Practices Have Faced Earlier Scrutiny

The Arizona lawsuit is also part of a broader debate over how the LDS Church handles allegations of childhood sexual abuse.

An Associated Press investigation (opens in a new tab) in 2022 examined the church’s abuse-reporting help line, which bishops use when they learn about suspected abuse.

The investigation raised concerns that calls involving child-abuse allegations were directed through church representatives and legal advisers rather than consistently resulting in reports to civil authorities.

The LDS Church has defended its procedures, maintaining that its help line assists religious leaders in complying with reporting requirements and protecting children.

The church has also emphasized its commitment to preventing abuse and supporting victims.

The current Supreme Court petition does not ask the justices to determine whether the church’s entire reporting system is unlawful.

Instead, it focuses on whether the Arizona Supreme Court interpreted federal constitutional protections too broadly when it shielded the bishops’ decisions not to report.

Will the U.S. Supreme Court Hear the Case?

That remains uncertain.

The survivors have filed a petition for a writ of certiorari, formally asking the Supreme Court to review the Arizona decision.

The justices must first decide whether to accept the case. They receive thousands of such petitions each year and agree to review relatively few.

If the Court declines, the Arizona Supreme Court’s ruling will remain in place.

If the justices accept the petition, the case could become an important test of the legal boundaries between religious confidentiality and mandatory child-abuse reporting.

For the three survivors, the stakes are more immediate.

They are seeking an opportunity to hold the LDS Church and its leaders accountable for failing to notify authorities while their father continued abusing them.

Related Coverage:

Arizona Supreme Court Lets Churches Decide When Abuse Confessions Remain Confidential

Arizona Appeals Court Revives Child Sex Abuse Lawsuit Against LDS Church

Arizona Court of Appeals Reinstates Part of LDS Child Abuse Lawsuit

Arizona Court of Appeals Reviews Case Involving LDS Bishop Accused of Failing to Report Child Abuse

GET A FREE CASE EVALUATION
no pressure. No obligation.

Knowledge Sparks Reform for Survivors.
Share This Story With Your Network.

Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success