Skip to content
Harvey Weinstein has been found guilty of sexual assault in a New York retrial, following the overturning of his 2020 conviction. A jury of seven women and five men delivered the verdict after five days of deliberations in a six-week trial. As the BBC reported yesterday, the panel unanimously convicted Weinstein on one count of sexual assault involving former production assistant Miriam Haley, while finding him not guilty of another charge involving model Kaja Sokola. A separate rape charge involving actress Jessica Mann remains undecided, with deliberations set to continue.
Details of the Trial and Accusations
The case centered on three women—Haley, Mann, and Sokola—who each accused Weinstein of using his influence in the entertainment industry to coerce and assault them. Weinstein’s legal team maintained that the encounters were consensual and portrayed them as part of an ongoing “friends with benefits” dynamic. Jurors heard extensive testimony detailing the abuse each woman said she suffered, including being attacked in hotels and private residences while seeking career opportunities.
Miriam Haley expressed hope that the verdict reflects growing awareness about sexual violence and the fading notion of a “perfect victim.” Kaja Sokola, whose accusation was introduced for the first time during the retrial, said, “Coming forward was the hardest thing I’ve ever done… Speaking out was an act of power and it allowed me to reclaim the pride and confidence he tried to take from me.”
Controversy Surrounding the Retrial
Weinstein’s retrial came after an appeals court threw out his original conviction, citing judicial error for allowing testimony from other women unrelated to the original charges. Weinstein was reindicted in September 2023.
Tensions among jurors were reported throughout deliberations, with the foreperson accusing others of bias and threats of physical altercations allegedly occurring. A judge intervened to remind jurors to focus only on the allegations presented in court.
Weinstein’s spokesperson called the trial fair until jury deliberations, citing complaints about jurors relying on preconceived notions. “We believe there are serious appellate issues and they will be explored,” the spokesperson said.
Ongoing Legal Fallout and Broader Impacts
Weinstein, who has multiple health conditions, remained hospitalized during the trial. He has not yet served a separate 16-year sentence in California following a 2022 conviction for similar offenses. In total, more than 100 women have accused Weinstein of sexual misconduct, though only a fraction of those claims have led to criminal convictions. A group of civil suits also resulted in a $19 million settlement in 2020.
The fall of Weinstein, once a Hollywood powerhouse and co-founder of Miramax, ignited the global #MeToo movement, encouraging thousands of survivors to come forward with their own experiences of abuse by powerful men.
To better understand the dynamics of power, coercion, and sexual abuse in the workplace, visit our page on quid pro quo sexual harassment.
