Skip to content
When it comes to sexual abuse within Christianity, most people equate the issue with the Catholic Church. The church’s tradition of celibacy, some argue, fosters a toxic environment that leads to sexual predation. However, recent scandals have shattered the notion that sexual abuse is confined to the Catholic denomination. The reality is that abuse is pervasive across many Christian groups, including the evangelical movement, where the root cause appears to be unchecked power, authority, and a lack of accountability—not celibacy.
In recent years, revelations of sexual misconduct within evangelical churches have sent shockwaves through the Christian community. High-profile cases, involving both prominent leaders and lesser-known clergy, have surfaced, revealing patterns of abuse, cover-ups, and institutional failure that rival even the Catholic Church’s well-documented crisis.
Recent Evangelical Scandals: A Disturbing Pattern
One of the most prominent cases involved Ravi Zacharias, a world-renowned apologist — the intellectual defense of the Christian faith — and author, whose reputation as a defender of the faith collapsed after his death in 2020. Investigations revealed that Zacharias engaged in years of sexual misconduct, exploiting his spiritual authority to manipulate and abuse women. Despite warnings from within his organization, Ravi Zacharias International Ministries (RZIM), his actions were kept secret for years, hidden behind his carefully cultivated public persona.
In 2019, the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC)—the largest Protestant denomination in the United States—faced its own reckoning. A Houston Chronicle investigation uncovered that over 700 victims of sexual abuse had been harmed by more than 380 SBC leaders and volunteers over the past two decades. The investigation revealed a culture of impunity, where allegations were routinely ignored, and abusers were often quietly moved to different congregations, with little regard for the victims.
Another high-profile case involves Bill Hybels, the influential pastor and founder of Willow Creek Community Church, who resigned in 2018 after multiple women came forward alleging they were sexually abused by him. Hybels led the megachurch for 40 years and only resigned after a Chicago Tribune investigation that revealed allegations of misconduct with women, including church employees that spanned decades.
The accusations against Hybels were initially dismissed by church leadership, only to later be substantiated, forcing a public apology from Willow Creek and prompting a larger conversation about how evangelical churches handle abuse allegations.
What Has the Evangelical Church Done to Address the Crisis?
In the wake of these revelations, the evangelical church has faced increasing pressure to confront the issue head-on. In 2019, the Southern Baptist Convention launched a Sexual Abuse Advisory Group, and during its annual meeting, it approved a series of measures designed to address sexual abuse within its churches. These included expelling congregations that knowingly hire or harbor sexual predators, improving training for church leaders on abuse prevention, and developing a database to track convicted or credibly accused pastors.
Many individual churches have begun to implement their own reforms, including establishing stricter vetting processes for leaders, improving transparency within leadership structures, and providing better support systems for victims. The evangelical community has also seen a rise in advocacy groups such as The Wartburg Watch and GRACE (Godly Response to Abuse in the Christian Environment), which have become vital resources for survivors of abuse within Christian settings.
What Do Experts Say Is the Cause of the Scandal?
Experts who have studied sexual abuse within evangelical churches point to several key factors contributing to the crisis. Central among them is the concentration of power within churches, where pastors and church leaders often wield near-absolute authority over their congregations. This dynamic can create an environment ripe for exploitation, as individuals in positions of power may be insulated from accountability, particularly in churches where questioning authority is discouraged.
There is also a culture of silence surrounding sexual abuse within evangelical communities. Victims are often pressured not to come forward, or they are disbelieved when they do, in part due to fears of damaging the church’s reputation. Some churches prioritize protecting the institution over the well-being of victims, leading to cover-ups and the quiet reassignment of accused leaders to different congregations—a problem similar to what has been seen in Catholic settings.
Additionally, evangelical churches often promote rigid gender roles that place men in positions of power and authority while encouraging submission from women. Critics argue that this hierarchical structure can contribute to an imbalance of power that fosters abuse. Boz Tchividjian, a former prosecutor and founder of GRACE, has argued that the evangelical church’s response to abuse is often inadequate because it fails to address the systemic issues of power and authority that make abuse possible.
Is the Evangelical Movement Doing Enough?
While some progress has been made, critics argue that the evangelical movement still has a long way to go in addressing the root causes of sexual abuse. Survivor advocates have pointed out that while the SBC and other evangelical bodies have taken steps to improve transparency and accountability, these efforts often fall short. For example, the Southern Baptist Convention’s proposed database of abusers remains controversial and has yet to be fully implemented, leaving many concerned that systemic problems persist.
Moreover, the evangelical movement’s continued resistance to external oversight poses a challenge. Unlike the Catholic Church, which operates under a centralized hierarchy, most evangelical churches are autonomous, meaning that reforms within one denomination or congregation do not necessarily apply to others. This decentralization can make it difficult to implement widespread change or enforce accountability across the movement.
In addition, evangelical churches often focus heavily on forgiveness and redemption, which can sometimes lead to perpetrators being reinstated in leadership roles after showing apparent remorse, even when victims’ concerns have not been fully addressed. Critics argue that the emphasis on forgiveness can be used as a tool to silence victims and perpetuate cycles of abuse.
Until these systemic issues are fully addressed, the scars of abuse will remain, and the evangelical church’s moral authority will continue to be questioned.
