Skip to content 
Photo: Archbishop Lori of the Archdiocese of Baltimore; via Wikipedia.
The Daily Record reports today that attorneys representing survivors of childhood sexual abuse have sharply criticized the Archdiocese of Baltimore’s proposal to contribute only $33 million toward resolving its bankruptcy case, calling the offer “insulting,” “reprehensible,” and “not even in the ballpark of fair or reasonable.”
Last week, the Archdiocese—America’s oldest—filed a proposed reorganization plan in bankruptcy court, outlining its intent to pay roughly $33.2 million, including funds from affiliated Catholic institutions. The Archdiocese suggested that insurance companies would cover “hundreds of millions” more, bringing total potential compensation higher. But for the more than 900 survivors who have filed claims, the Church’s direct payment would average about $35,000 per person.
The survivors’ committee countered with its own plan demanding nearly $889 million from the Archdiocese and its affiliates before any insurance payouts. Under their proposal, the Archdiocese alone would contribute $615 million, with parishes, schools, and related Catholic entities covering the balance.
“Their plan—if you want to call it a plan—is ridiculous and meaningless in terms of getting this bankruptcy resolved,” said a plaintiff’s attorney who represents many of the victims. He added that for two years, the Archdiocese has failed to engage in good faith negotiations.
Another attorney representing a significant portion of the claimants said he was “offended” by the offer, noting it came as a surprise to many survivors. “It is objectively not even in the ballpark of fair or reasonable to the survivors of sexual abuse at the hands of the church and its employees,” he said.
The Archdiocese’s position leans heavily on the doctrine of charitable immunity—a legal principle arguing that funds donated for religious or charitable purposes cannot be used to pay legal judgments. The Church maintains that it is voluntarily offering $33 million even if it prevails on that claim. Critics argue that this stance is another attempt to shield assets while minimizing accountability.
“It’s about the most insulting way you can pay a claim,” said one attorney, adding that the offer contradicts statements made by Archbishop William Lori, who has said the Church accepts responsibility and seeks to bring healing to victims. “It doesn’t feel like this matches that message,” said another lawyer, calling the offer “woefully inadequate.”
Survivors also expressed anger and exhaustion at the Church’s approach. “Everybody’s getting up in years, and there’s no light at the end of the tunnel,” said a survivor who also represents other survivors victims and filed her own claim. “They’re just running from accountability. I don’t believe a word they say.”
Archbishop Lori, in a statement last week, acknowledged the need for urgency but did not respond to survivors’ criticisms directly. “While there is still much work to do, I am hopeful this form plan will aid us in ongoing conversations and will allow us to move forward toward a quicker resolution,” he said. “With every day that passes, the suffering of victim-survivors is prolonged.”
Related Stories:
Survivors Seek Dismissal of Baltimore Archdiocese Bankruptcy Case
Judge rules Baltimore Archdiocese victims can continue testimony in court
Survivors Still Waiting as Baltimore Archdiocese’s Bankruptcy Case Drags On
Judge Clears Path for Baltimore Archdiocese Abuse Survivors to Sue Before Damages Cap Takes Effect
Baltimore Archdiocese Accused of Hiding Behind Charitable Immunity to Avoid Paying Abuse Survivors
For Survivors of Catholic Church Sexual Abuse
If you or someone you love suffered sexual abuse within the Catholic Church, you may still have legal options. Survivors across the country are stepping forward to seek justice, accountability, and healing.
Visit our Catholic Church Sexual Abuse Lawsuit Guide to learn more about your rights and how you can take the first step toward holding the Church accountable.
